Picky Barista
Sign in to add a photo.
About
Picky Barista is a coffee shop in Manhattan, United States, with a price range of $1–10. It is known for serving lattes, cookies, and pastries. The venue offers amenities including takeaway, breakfast, and a bar.
In context
- Rated 4.5 — in the top 43% of 92 cafés in Manhattan with 25 or more ratings (12 share this rating).
- About 4 min walk from 86th Street (283 m in a straight line).
- 12 other specialty cafés within 500 m.
- In the cheap price tier, like 47% of the 64 cafés in Manhattan with a listed price.
- Opens before 8am on weekdays — 80% of the 111 cafés in Manhattan with listed hours do.
Menu highlights
- Special
- Stumptown Retail Beans
- El Jordan is a juicy cup, layered with notes of candied apple.
- Add egg +$1.75
- Add avocado +$1.5
- Add banana or blueberry +$0.75
- Using Mama’s recipe, our apple cake is moist and rich in flavor
- Rolled with Nutella throughout, our roll is soft and tasty
- A crowd-pleaser, our banana bread is deliciously satisfying
- Flaky dough layered with creamy feta and baked until golden
- Same recipe as our regular banana bread but without the gluten
Amenities
What customers mention
- Service4
- Ambiance4
- Food & drink quality2
Frequently asked questions
Where is Picky Barista?+
Picky Barista is located at 1220 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10028, United States, Manhattan.
What kind of place is Picky Barista?+
Picky Barista is a Coffee Shop in Manhattan.
What are Picky Barista's opening hours?+
Picky Barista is open seven days a week.
Is Picky Barista open on Sundays?+
Yes, Picky Barista is open on Sundays.
When is the best time to visit Picky Barista?+
It is busiest on Saturday and usually quietest on Thursday.
How expensive is Picky Barista?+
Picky Barista is generally budget-friendly.
What does Picky Barista offer?+
Picky Barista offers Takeaway, Breakfast, Laptop friendly, Wheelchair access, Free Wi-Fi, Family friendly, Parking, Serves alcohol.
What is Picky Barista good for?+
Picky Barista is a popular choice for Working / laptops.
When is Picky Barista busiest?+
Picky Barista is typically busiest on Saturday in the afternoon.
How do customers rate Picky Barista?+
Picky Barista has an average rating of 4.5★ from 350 reviews. 86% of ratings are 4 stars or more.
What is Picky Barista known for?+
Picky Barista is known for latte, cookie, pastry, banana bread, cake. Menu highlights include Special, Stumptown Retail Beans, El Jordan is a juicy cup, layered with notes of candied apple..
Is Picky Barista a specialty coffee shop?+
Yes, Picky Barista is a specialty coffee shop.
Location
What customers say
In recent Google reviews, Service is mentioned most often (4 times). 86% of ratings give 4 stars or more. It is a specialty coffee shop. Reviewers also highlight Ambiance, Food & drink quality. Customers often visit for Working / laptops. It is typically busiest on Saturday in the afternoon. Drinks customers recommend include latte, cookie, pastry, banana bread, cake.
Summarised from themes in recent Google reviews.
Reviews
No reviews yet — be the first to review Picky Barista.
Other locations
Similar coffee shops
More coffee shops in Manhattan




